Allysa B. Peyton

Allysa B. Peyton

Allysa B. Peyton

Katherine Ann Paul

Arts of South Asia: Cultures of Collecting

Arts of South Asia: Cultures of Collecting
Edited by Allysa B. Peyton and Katherine Anne Paul.
University Press of Florida, 2019.

In Arts of South Asia: Cultures of Collecting, coeditors Allysa B. Peyton and Katherine Ann Paul draw us into the personal, institutional and political dynamics surrounding objects that have journeyed from South Asia India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Bhutan to museums abroad and, in one case, undergone repatriation. We learn how individuals and some of the many women donors of Newark Museum in New Jersey acquired works; how collectors and curators interpreted and exhibited them; and how, in a few instances, institutions returned them to their country of origin. We also meet a lively mix of collectors, from towering figures like Ananda Coomaraswamy and Chester Beatty to British civil servants and American missionaries. Whether works are carved doors, Mughal paintings, bidriware from South Central India or statuary from Hindu temples, their stories address universal questions of representation and ownership. And the timespan of these case studies from the early 1800s to the 2010s-highlights the changes in attitudes and values. Peyton and Paul, recently sat down with AramcoWorld to explain more about their book and why they chose to lean in on South Asia.


Tell me why you both chose to examine collectors of South Asian art?

Peyton: We refer to the imprint individual collectors have on our institutions.

Paul: In Hyder Abbas's essay, for example, Chester Beatty is negotiating with British Museum and V&A curators, essentially divvying up certain "great works" and developing canon that prized Mughal painting over other kinds of painting from South Asia.

Peyton: There's Hugh Nevill in Shushma Jansary's essay: He's a botanist, an insect-lover, and he's collecting everything! So, the Nevill Collection at the British Museum has things formerly termed folk art. They were marginalized but now, for the first time, they've been properly photographed and published.

Paul: There's a feedback loop that once you create an authoritative volume, its images become the masterworks. That's why we were so careful to include images that were not just ones people were used to seeing. We wanted to add to. not underscore, existing masterpiece narratives.

Was Mughal painting popular with early collectors? Why is that significant?

Paul: With palm-leaf manuscripts, you had to wrap your head around their being long and not bound-but illustrated Shahnamahs or Hamzanamas were akin to medieval manuscripts. Even seeing Arabic on the page was familiar from the Nasrids in Spain.

Peyton: Mughal painting had imperial patronage, too. You have studios bringing in regional artists who learn from each other. I think that, too, helped set the taste standard for several centuries.

Paul: The fact that Mughal paintings occur in a number of the book's essays demonstrates how they're woven into a greater tapestry of South Asian arts-it is useful to recognize this in these times of polarization globally.

How is recent scholarship shaping exhibition strategies?

Paul: Music and dance are inextricable from, say, a carving in the South Asian context, and in the diaspora the gathering is valued so much more than having beautiful items in a gallery, inactivated. So, Gauri Krishnan's essay talks about bringing in intangible cultural environments. That's the direction in which things have to continue to go.

What does that mean for Islamic art?

Peyton: Bringing in poetry, music, dance, video, maybe smells—

Paul: —the alliteration and cadence of Farsi poetry or excerpts from the Qur'an to provide an aural addition. I've now seen where they will have the call to prayer from five different locales, so you can hear regional differentiations.

Peyton: We need more of these connections between academia and museum practice. And it works out really well because it's a lot more fun and interactive, and it can bring in a range of visitors.