Analyzing Complicated Relationships in Art
Anthropology
Culture
Visual Arts
North Africa
Western Europe
Juliet Highet
At the heart of “Hassan Hajjaj’s Hot Remix” is the Arabic term noss-noss, which translates to half-half. More broadly, the term suggests a mixing. “Hajjaj’s Hot Remix” reveals mixing, both in Hassan Hajjaj’s life and in his art. It describes how Hajjaj immigrated from Morocco to London when he was 12 and drew from his own mixed identity to create art that mixes both media (photography, fashion design, sculpture) and cultures. Writer Juliet Highet argues that Hajjaj’s work is subtly (and often humorously) subversive, and she uses the concept of cultural appropriation to analyze the complicated relationship between the art of the West and the art of Northern Africa. The activities included here focus on the concepts of subversion, irony and cultural appropriation.
IF YOU ONLY HAVE 15 MINUTES ...
Hassan Hajjaj’s art often includes critiques of consumer culture, a way of life (culture) that emphasizes buying things (consuming). Write a statement referring to examples that summarizes what you think Hajjaj is saying about consumer culture in his work.
IF YOU ONLY HAVE 30 MINUTES ...
Irony refers to expressing meaning by using words or images that are the opposite of what you mean. Explain, either in writing or by speaking, what is ironic in the Hassan Hajjaj’s artwork and test your ability to recognize and explain irony by finding a political cartoon that uses it.
VISUAL ANALYSIS
Analyze one of Hassan Hajjaj’s artworks, using provided questions to guide you. You can either answer them in writing, or in discussion with a partner.
Hajjaj’s Hot Remix: The Remixed Version
Noss-noss.
That’s how Hassan Hajjaj has been described. It’s an Arabic term that literally translates as “half-half.” Hassan Hajjaj is an artist, and half-half describes both the man and his work.
Hajjaj himself was born in Morocco, but moved to London when he was 12. He identifies as “a human being first, and then as a Moroccan, a North African, and as a Londoner.” He is a mixture.
Noss-noss also describes Hajjaj’s art. He works in different media, including photography, fashion and furniture, video, and sculpture. In addition to mixing materials, he also mixes visual elements from different people and cultures.
He mixes them with a sense of play, and of purpose. His images are sometimes gently subversive and satirical. They play with gender expectations and consumerism. They also subtly comment on the meanings of noss-noss identities.
Hajjaj has had several major showings of his work. One was called Carte Blanche, which is French for blank paper. It’s a metaphor for having the freedom to do what you want. The objects in the exhibit show Hajjaj’s noss-noss. They include images of street life in different cities, including Marrakesh, London, Lagos, Johannesburg, and New York.
But the noss-noss quality involves more than just images from different locations. It also subverts expectations in order to make a point. To subvert means to disrupt or unsettle. For example, some of Hajjaj’s photos play with the image of women wearing veils. Wearing the veil is expected for Muslim women. Some non-Muslims think that wearing the veil oppresses women. Hajjaj’s images play with both points of view.
“The veil is still worn because of tradition,” he says, bowing to the expectation that women wear veils. At the same time Hajjaj’s art questions those who criticize the veil. He says, “I’m not putting women behind veils to repress them. In fact there’s flirtatiousness behind it in my photographs. I’m trying to emphasize the mischievous aspect. It’s doubled-edged,” he explains. On one hand, he accepts the traditional understanding of the veil – that women are not seen in public. On the other, he defies both the veil itself and the critique that it oppresses women: the women in his photos are flirting.
“Look how modern and defiant they are,” he says. “They’re blending tradition with pop fashion.” Noss-noss.
Hajjaj also uses irony in his artwork to make a point. A lot of typical fashion photography shows Western models in Western clothes posing in “exotic” (Eastern) locations. Vogue, the Arab Issue turns that on its head. One image shows two Moroccan women wearing bright, flashy versions of traditional djellabas (robes) and babouches (slippers). They are reading Vogue and Elle through cheap, comical sunglasses. Bottles of Coca-Cola rest on the table between them. By showing something so different from the usual, this image makes the reader laugh at the traditional images—and maybe question them, too.
Hajjaj’s art developed from his life as an immigrant. He moved from Morocco to London when he was 12. He had a hard time fitting in. He ended up, with others, embracing many cultures. He was drawn to American hip-hop, funk and soul music, and also to reggae.
In 1984, Hajjaj opened a fashion shop on London’s hip Carnaby Street. He called it R.A.P., which stood for “Real Artistic People.” R.A.P. became a popular place for artists to hang out.
Around the same time, Hajjaj learned photography, and started using photos to express his noss-noss identity. But it wasn’t until 2006 that he decided he might be ready to show his photos. Hajjaj called his friend Rose Issa, who promotes Arab arts in London. She was dazzled. He had his first solo exhibition in the UK in 2008
Hajjaj’s photos reveal another aspect of his work’s noss-noss: the many ways people express different parts of their identities. Issa notes that the people in the photos “sometimes look menacing but have a smile in their eyes.” She, too, notes the sense of play around women’s roles. One of the women who posed for Hajjaj winks at the viewer above her veil. Another shows a bit of leg astride a motorbike.
The photos also show the noss-noss of the subjects’ class status and their ambitions. Many of the women in Hajjaj’s photos eke out a living painting henna designs on tourists. But they still want to “look grand,” as he puts it. “For people [in Africa] who don’t have money, looking great alleviates the pain of poverty. And this becomes street chic.”
It’s street chic that Hajjaj creates, using cheap materials that he finds here and there. In his London shop, for example, he has made red plastic Coca-Cola crates into chairs. He uses road and shop signs as tabletops. And he uses product tins as light fixtures.
Hajjaj remixes these “repurposed” items. His work makes them noss-noss. The art that results celebrates discarded items. It’s a new take on the culture of poor people. And it’s very different from the traditional Orientalist point of view. Orientalism was an 1800s-art movement that showed Arab and Asian people and culture as exotic. It did this by exaggerating and distorting parts of their cultures.
In his art, Hajjaj exaggerates and distorts parts of Western consumer culture instead of Arab culture. In that way, he undermines, or subverts, it. “For me, being Moroccan, it’s taking ownership, control of that fantasy idea and giving that back to our own people,” he explains. It is, in a way, another kind of recycling.
Hajjaj wants his photography to “become more like teaching rather than pretty pictures.” In this way, he subverts the common purpose of art itself.
Finally, Hajjaj aims to reach a mixed – noss-noss – audience. “I want my photography to communicate with somebody like myself, who originally wouldn’t go to a gallery, as well as somebody who’s an intellectual,” he says. “I want it to appeal to everyone, whether they’re a cleaner or an art critic.”
Other lessons
Breaking the Shanidar Neanderthal Stereotype: Evidence Based Analysis
Archeology
History
Museum Studies
Middle East
For over a century, archeologists believed Neanderthals were brutish, unintelligent and emotionless. They theorized Neanderthals were not directly related to modern-day humans. Recent archeological studies have dispelled many of these myths through DNA and archeological analysis. Lesson activities have students analyze these stereotypes and recent scientific evidence to the contrary.Developing Inquiry Questions Around the Study of Infectious Diseases
Environmental Studies
Science
Middle East
During 2020 the world needed some superheroes. Among all the frontline workers who helped the world get through the pandemic were epidemiologists who worked like crime detectives to sift through evidence and solve medical mysteries.Training Somaliland's Next Generation of Caregivers: Identifying the Thesis and Supporting Arguments
Biography
Culture
Geography
Women Studies
East Africa
Now in her 80s, Edna Adan has, during her long life, been a midwife, educator and public-health pioneer. Conduct a close reading exercise to find the thesis of the article, identify evidence that supports the thesis and develop questions for further investigation.