
Essays Unpack the Evolving Hajj and Umrah Experience
Reviewed by Jamie S. Scott
Narrating the Pilgrimage to Mecca: Historical and Contemporary Accounts
Marjo Buitelaar and Richard van Leeuwen, eds. Brill. 2023.
“Narratives do not simply give words to experiences, but experiences themselves are shaped by words.”
Narrating the Pilgrimage to Mecca reveals how pilgrim stories actively reinvent the Hajj and Umrah, journeys to Makkah, across centuries. Edited by Marjo Buitelaar and Richard van Leeuwen, both experts in Islamic studies, the volume juxtaposes historical first-hand narratives of Hajj and Umrah journeys with oral interviews of contemporary pilgrims to show the transformative power of storytelling. The historical section features a 16th-century Spanish poem, Ottoman records and a historical novel of Tajik journalist Fazliddin Muhammadiev’s extraordinary 1963 Soviet-era journey, among other accounts. These narratives contrast sharply with today’s accounts. The ethnographic examination of Dutch Moroccan vlogs, African American conversion stories and Moroccan women’s smartphone diaries reflect a welcoming exploration of how such narratives thrive on intended audiences, emotional responses and feelings of home. What emerges is a living tradition continually reshaped by its storytellers. Where 16th-century chroniclers framed Hajj as geopolitical theater, today’s digital narratives turn it into intimate spiritual theater. The editor’s thoughtful selection of 16 essays demonstrates this evolution. Muhammadiev’s smuggled manuscript alongside an Indonesian nurse’s text messages, proves pilgrimage survives through reinvention. Both editors’ combined expertise ensures both the 18th-century Moroccan scholar’s ink-and-parchment account and the 2020s social media posts receive equally nuanced readings—reminding us that every media format, from manuscripts to pixels, writes Islam’s living tradition.
You may also be interested in...
Celebrate Women's History Month With These Reads on Women Throughout History
To help honor Women’s History Month, AramcoWorld brings you a list of 10 female-focused reads that celebrate women throughout history.The Ebb and Flow of History on the Zambezi River
In tracing the past six centuries of history, historian Malyn Hewitt captures the cyclical rise and fall of the river and its people.British Library’s 500-Year-Old Nizami Manuscripts Shed Light on Power of Art and Poetry in 12th-Century Herat
Persian and Mughal scholar and specialist Barbara Brend presents a comprehensive study of one of the most highly esteemed works of Persian Literature.