Caliphate: The History of an Idea
By Hugh Kennedy
2016, Basis Books, 978-0-46509-438-7, $27.99 hb.
Reviewed on January 1, 0001
Misappropriated today by those seeking to impose “their particular and often very narrow view of Islam” onto others, the caliphate is instead “a framework in which Muslims can strive to live a godly life,” writes scholar Hugh Kennedy. The “Arabic root khalafa,” means to “succeed or deputize.” The caliph was a successor to Muhammad as head of the Islamic community, or umma. The role embraced spiritual, fiscal and military responsibilities under the broadly unified system known as the “caliphate.” Kennedy covers the major historical caliphal regimes: the foundational nature of the first four “rightly guided” caliphs (the Rashidun) of the seventh century and the land-hungry, authoritative character of their successors, the Umayyads; the “extraordinary explosion of cultural activity” under the 13th-century Abbasids and medieval Moors of Andalusia; and the “role of the sultan as caliph” under the Ottomans. He concludes that the strength of the caliphate “lies partly in its flexibility”—hardly a virtue embraced by extremists who lack the “intellectual justification” Kennedy explores in this enlightening text.